The Hacking Trial Costs Issue – News UK withdraw their claim for millions: Saunders’ Memo

Back in June, when Rebekah Brooks, Stuart Kuttner, Cheryl Carter and Mark Hanna were all acquitted at the phone hacking trial, their barristers made it clear they would be applying (as is their right) for a refund of their court costs. Already, at this point, it was clear that News UK would have to be party to these hearings on costs, since they had indemnified all the cleared defendants bar Charlie Brooks. The initial quantum for that claim was reported to be £25 million in legal costs. This was reduced two weeks ago to £7 million by the Crown Prosecution Service on the basis of equivalent legal aid, rather than private, legal costings.  Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 11 June

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Wednesday 11 June 2014

Summary
The Summing Up Continues on Count 7
Mr Justice Sanders continues on the Removal of Evidence
The Summing Up of Evidence on Count 2 and 3
The Evidence of purchasing Royal Directories and Royal Green Books
The Summing Up of Evidence on Count 5
The Evidence of paying a Public Official
Mr Justice Saunders Concludes the Trial
Corrections to Evidence
Jury presented with Electronic copies of the Evidence
The Judge retires the Jury to consider their verdicts

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 10 June

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Tuesday 10 June 2014

Summary
The Summing Up Continues on Count 1
The last full day of Justice Saunders Summing Up
Justice Saunders QC continues his review of Count 1
Goodman pleads Guilty
Coulson’s Resignation
Brooks job offer to Goodman
The Guardian Hacking article in 2009
Email Deletion Policy
The Summing Up of Evidence on Count 6
Count 6 and the Archived Boxes
The Summing Up of Evidence on Count 7
Count 7 and the Removal of Evidence

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 4 June

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Wednesday 4 June 2014

Summary
The Summing Up
Justice Saunders QC presents Legal Direction and his Summing Up
Mr Justice Saunders Legal Direction to the Jury
The Judge Complete his Legal Directions
Mr Justice Saunders Summing Up and Review of the Evidence
The Judge Reviews the Evidence
Sentiment and Emotion
Accusations against the Police
The Judge talks about the Defendants
Evidence on Count One
The Milly Dowler Story

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 3 June

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Tuesday 3 June 2014

Summary
Charlie Brooks Closing Statement
Neil Saunders QC presents the Closing Statement for Charlie Brooks
Summary of Charlie Brooks background
The events of 2011
Rebekah Brooks Arrest
Missing devices
Mark Hanna Closing Statement
William Clegg QC presents the Closing Statement for Mark Hanna
Hanna’s Background
Legal Directions
The Prosecution Case against Hanna
The Events of July 2011
The Fire Pit Evidence
Twelve Points that Prove Innocence

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 21 May

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Wednesday 21 May 2014

Summary
Rebekah Brooks Closing Statement continues
Closing Statement continues on Count 1 with the evidence of Eimear Cook
Closing Statement on Count 5
Closing Statement on Counts 6 and 7
Closing Statement on Count 7
Allegation of Corporate Cover Up
Email Deletion Policy
Rebekah Brooks Defence concludes its Closing Statement

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 19 May

Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News

Monday 19 May 2014

Summary
The Prosecutions Cross-Examination of Clive Goodman Continues
Clive Goodman questioned about Palace Royal Protection
The Hacking of Royal Phones
Goodman’s Arrest in 2011
Clive Goodman questioned further by his own Counsel
Counsel for Clive Goodman closes his Defence
The Judge has some final questions for Clive Goodman
Justice Saunders provides further Direction to the Jury
Changes to the Indictment Sheet
Directions on Counts 2 and 3
The Prosecution continues its Closing Statement
Anthony Edis QC presents his closing statement on Count 6 and 7
Further Closing Statement on Count 1, 2 and 3

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 8 Apr

Tuesday 8 April 2014

Summary
Mr Justice Saunders – Order of Proceedings
Defendant Mark Hanna to be followed by Stuart Kuttner
Defence Admissions for Mark Hanna
Counsel for Hanna reads admissions
The Defence of Stuart Kuttner Begins
Jonathan Caplan QC Introduces the Defence Case for Stuart Kuttner
Stuart Kuttner’s recent Medical History
Stuart Kuttner answers questions on his Career in Journalism
Kuttner joins News of the World
Kuttner’s Role as Managing Editor
Member of Press Council
Kuttner’s Contract with the News of the World
Kuttner is asked for his view of other members of staff at NOTW
Kuttner questioned on Contributor Payment Requests
Limit of Payments and Levels of Authorisation
Cash Payments
Goodman Payments 2005
Goodman’s Confidential Source and Alexander Payments
Kuttner’s work on Budget Setting
Attempts to cut Nine Consultancy Budget
Editorial Budget
Mr Justice Saunders Reviews the Position of the Trial
Clive Goodman expected to return in May

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 7 Apr

Monday 7 April 2014

Summary
Mr Justice Saunders explains order of Defendants
Clive Goodman still not well
Defence Witnesses for Mark Hanna
Witness for Hanna – John Stonewick (Father in Law)
The Prosecution cross-examine John Stonewick
Witness for Hanna – Will Smith (Excellence Analyst for Pizza Hut)
The Prosecution cross-examine Will Smith
The Defence of Charlie Brooks continues with Defence Witnesses
Witness for Charlie Brooks – Mark Prescott (Race Horse Trainer)
Witness for Charlie Brooks – Sir Thomas Lacey (Racehorse Owner)
Witness Statement for Charlie Brooks – Kevin Perry (Daily Telegraph)
Witness for Charlie Brooks – Jo Russell (Former PA)
Witness for Charlie Brooks – Sarah Bradstock (Friend)
Charlie Brooks and Fairy Liquid

Continue reading

Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 4 Apr

Friday 4 April 2014

Summary
Mark Hanna’s Defence continues with Character Witnesses
Witness for Hanna – Simon Bowskill, a former Army colleague
Witness for Hanna – Michael Bluestone, Security Consultant
Witness for Hanna – Michael Alexander, Corporate Security Consultant
Witness for Hanna – Kirstie Millett, a friend
Witness for Hanna – Marva Ingram, Executive Receptionist at News UK
Marva Ingram Cross Examined by the Prosecution

Continue reading