Tuesday 25 February 2014
Summary | ||
Rebekah Brooks Defence Continues on Finance at News of the World | ||
Brooks questioned on Budgets and Overspend | ||
Glen Mulcaire Contracts | ||
Affects of 9/11 Attacks | ||
Weekly Budgets | ||
Never heard of Glen Mulcaire | ||
The Milly Dowler Story | ||
Rebekah Brooks question on the use of Mobile Phones and Hacking | ||
Use of mobile phones | ||
Aware of voicemail hacking | ||
Didn’t know it was hacking was illegal | ||
Rebekah Brooks question on the Hacking of Milly Dowlers Phone | ||
Shocked at the hacking of Milly Dowlers phone | ||
Brooks in Dubai when the Milly Dowler story running | ||
Run through of the Milly Dowler Timeline | ||
Mention of Voicemails removed from Milly Dowler article | ||
Kuttner email to Surrey Police |
Rebekah Brooks Defence Continues on Finance at News of the World | ||
Brooks questioned on Budgets and Overspend | ||
Back at the #hackingtrial with Rebekah Brooks continuing her defence, questioned by her counsel, Jonathan Laidlaw QC | ||
Laidlaw takes us to a page in his defence bundle: cites a prosecution document – email from Kuttner 12/06/01 to Judy McGuire | ||
Brooks explains Kuttner email: it’s about a purchase of photographs some of which weren’t used. | ||
03/06/01 has follow up email to Brooks from Judy McGuire about pictures desk going over budget. | ||
“The Sunday Magazine had quite a small budget compared to the main newspaper,” Brooks explains about NOTW internal email | ||
“It would have been a constant theme trying to make sense of that overspend,” says Brooks of £1m overspend by NOTW pictures desk in 2001 | ||
Brooks goes through another 05/07/01 internal email from Kuttner going through NOTW budget: £247k for Sarah’s Campaign | ||
The “For Sarah – Sarah’s Law Campaign” costs came out of the editorial budget says Brooks. | ||
Actually the budget was £275k for NOTW Sarah’s Law campaign in 2001 | ||
Another Kuttner email 14/07/01, two weeks into 2001-2 budget, cited by Laidlaw, going through weekly spending limits at NOTW | ||
Email from Brooks 26/07/01 to Greg Miskiw, David Jarvis (features) and Clare Wood (pictures) listing a series of possible stories on NOTW | ||
“By Thursday night as the editor I’d be checking the stories for the weekend,” Brooks says of her email in 2001. | ||
Same email chain to Geoff Webster and Harry Scott: “No need to read it out, it may be libellous,” says Justice Saunders. | ||
Brooks explains how the email is about MPs taking holidays. The follow up from Brooks refers to the Carvery diary | ||
“Paul McCartney is engaged,” writes Harry Scott to Brooks: She replies: “How do you know?” “On PA” Brooks replies “Good” | ||
Laidlaw cites 15/08/01 Kuttner email (seen before) writes to NOTW budget holders about contributor payments. | ||
Glen Mulcaire Contracts | ||
Laidlaw now goes through the two long term contracts for Glenn Mulcaire signed by Greg Miskiw, senior editor under Brooks at NOTW | ||
The contract goes into detail on Mulcaire research assignments: £92k for first year 2001 | ||
Brooks explains that at this point Greg Miskiw was an assistant editor at News and Investigations at this point in 2001. | ||
Brooks says she never saw £92k Mulcaire contract “during my editorship” and never head of EuroResearch | ||
“We used a lot of private detectives, so it wouldn’t necessarily rang a bell,” says Brooks of Mulcaire’s Euro Research company. | ||
“The use of private detectives… at that time in Fleet St was pretty normal,” says Brooks of hypothetical reaction had she seen contract | ||
BREAKING Brooks says Mulcaire £94k contract “should have been authorised by me and Stuart Kuttner” but says she never saw it. | ||
The Mulcaire annual payment should have been flagged up, says Brooks. Weekly payments “wouldn’t necessarily come to me” | ||
Brooks on private detectives in 2001: “Because I came up the features route… I didn’t use that many private detectives” | ||
“Across Fleet St and other industries, late 90s to about 2003, there was a lot of use of private detectives,” says Brooks at #hackingtrial | ||
“They do the legwork for journalists,” says Brooks, and uses example of “tracking down paedophiles” | ||
Justice Saunders says of using PIs to track down 5 paedophiles: “You put them on the frontpage and asked if anyone knew where they were” | ||
Affects of 9/11 Attacks | ||
Laidlaw now cites coverage of 9/11 attacks in NOTW in September 2001. | ||
Laidlaw for Brooks goes through emails from Greg Miskiw to James Morgan (in Finance) for “Williams” AKA Mulcaire | ||
22/09/01 Miskiw email to Brooks about footballers in a hotel and behaving in a bad way during 9/11. “Maybe it was Chelsea I can’t remember” | ||
02/10/01 Kuttner email to desk heads, copied to Brooks and Coulson, about rebudgeting in light economic impact of 9/11 | ||
11/10/01 Another Kuttner email cc’ed to Brooks: “News International Cost Review” – mentions ad revenue falling and job losses, hiring freeze | ||
“Any rise in paper prices has a huge impact on a newspaper,” Brooks explains of economic climate post 9/11 and fears of global recession | ||
Brooks explains they had to reduce “casual dockets” – temporary employees – in wake of 9/11 attacks. | ||
Brooks explained she needed a new designed in 2001 because she was hoping to launch a NOTW “Lads Mag… a bit like GQ” | ||
Weekly Budgets | ||
Another document goes through the different Weekly Spending Limits – WSLs – of various desk heads at NOTW | ||
Editorial management weekly budget revised in 2001 from £18,845 to £16,840 | ||
Documents show the NOTW weekly budget of News and Investigation revised down in 2001 from £41,650 to £37,675 | ||
Laidlaw cites a BBC News report saying the fears of a global recession in late October 2001 post 9/11 were dissipating. | ||
November 2001: Kuttner writes to Miskiw about “budget bonus scheme” for first quarter and a cheque for £1k | ||
“It was just a way to incentivize people,” says Brooks of bonus scheme she introduced. Miskiw on budget so no investigation of his spend | ||
Brooks talks about “Bulger Killers” story and restrictions on report Thompson and Venables new lives. | ||
“If they broke their license conditions, that might be something the media could report,” says Brooks of Thompson and Venables in 2001. | ||
Never heard of Glen Mulcaire | ||
“I never heard the name Mulcaire before he was arrested… but Greg might have said it was one of my great contacts,” says Brooks | ||
Brooks emails Bill Akass and Harry Scott on a Saturday night in 2001 about “rivals” front pages | ||
“The bigger the circulation of the papers, the earlier they had to print” Brooks says of Sunday rivals Mirror and Mail | ||
“Match mail on Sunday on Hurley” says Brooks email: she explains this means “Could we take from Mail on Sunday and add it to our piece” | ||
Brooks email 2001 asks whether a NOTW story about “Injured SAS soldier” came “anonymously” and cites another “Sophie” (C of Wessex) story | ||
Another £1k bonus for Miskiw for Kuttner in 2001: Brooks said it’s “possible” this was brought to her attention. | ||
“I don’t particularly remember Greg being the only one to get this bonus,” Brooks says of Miskiw cheque | ||
Now in Feb 2002: Brooks writes to Clare Wood about falls in “ad revenue… I’m taking serious consequences if we don’t make it happen” | ||
“It’s the picture desk again,” Brooks says of a NOTW department over shooting the budget. | ||
March 2002 NOTW budget documents now re-examined by Laidlaw, having been cited by the prosecution previously. | ||
“I had an authorisation for £50k but can’t remember when that came in,” says Brooks. Finance document makes Brooks a category 3 | ||
Laidlaw now comes to the subject of Milly Dowler. The jury are given a new bundle. | ||
15 minute break. | ||
The Milly Dowler Story | ||
Back at #hackingtrial after the break: Rebekah Brooks is now addressing the Milly Dower story. | ||
Laidlaw says he will “sketch in the time period” and refers the jury to their timelines | ||
Brooks has various files now on the witness stand – at least three big ring binders. She takes out the Milly Dowler timeline | ||
The amended Dubai times on this new timeline has been agreed by both sides. | ||
Laidlaw picks up the essential features of the chronology: Milly disappears 21/03/02 covered by NOTW 23/03/02 | ||
Brooks’ week long holiday began on 07/04/02 in Dubai. Dowler’s voicemail access on or after 10/04/02 | ||
13/04/02 The first edition of NOTW citing her voicemails. Brooks returned on 14/04/02. Kuttner emails Surrey police following week. | ||
Saunders adds another date – 12/04/02 – activity in Telford around Milly Dowler. | ||
Rebekah Brooks question on the use of Mobile Phones and Hacking | ||
Use of mobile phones | ||
Brooks is asked by Laidlaw when she first got a mobile telephone: “I think early 90s,” she says. | ||
Brooks thinks journalists would have acquired mobile phones earlier than the general public in the 90s. | ||
“You would have to file your story on a public phone to copy takers… before any mobile phones,” says Brooks of early adoption of mobiles | ||
“I do remember that the industry, compared to some of my pals… it was a unique thing,” says Brooks of mobile phones in early days. | ||
Brooks says she became aware of voicemail messages in “mid 90s maybe a bit later.” | ||
Aware of voicemail hacking | ||
Brooks says she first became aware of voicemail hacking and “factory default setting…. came to my attention by late 90s” #hackingtrial | ||
“There was some publicity about high profile people… by late 90s maybe and definitely early 2000s” says Brooks. | ||
“By the time as deputy editor of the Sun, I don’t remember it being an issue then,” says Brooks of phone hacking in late 90s | ||
BREAKING: Brooks says she was never asked to sanction phone hacking as part of an investigation. | ||
Brooks on phone hacking: “it depends on the kind of story…. is accessing voicemails going to give you the kind of info you require | ||
“I can’t see how accessing voicemails would have helped those stories,” says Brooks of most her big NOTW exclusives like Countess of Wessex | ||
Of usefulness of hacking to desk heads Brooks says: “I suppose the showbusiness dept if it was looking for tittle tattle over a celebrity” | ||
Didn’t know it was hacking was illegal | ||
“At the time… my editorship of NOTW, I don’t think anybody knew it was illegal,” says Brooks of phone hacking 2000-03 | ||
“No desk head, no journalist, ever came to me and said… we need to access their voicemails or ask for my sanction,” says Brooks | ||
“Even though I didn’t know it was illegal, anything like that was in the category of invading someone’s privacy,” says Brooks on hacking. | ||
Brooks says she’s “pretty sure” she never heard of RIPA Act (making phone hacking illegal) “until 2006” | ||
Brooks speaks of the editors code being updated to reflect an “industry failure” and how the laws around privacy changed and ECHR article 8 | ||
Again Brooks says she never approved phone hacking during her editorship of NOTW. | ||
“I don’t think it was,” says Brooks of any story in NOTW relying on phone hacking. | ||
Brooks talks about Mulcaire’s arrest in 2006 and a piece by David Leigh using phone hacking around an arms dealing investigation | ||
Brooks says she might have considered hacking “if something to do with paedophiles or Sarah Payne’s murder… But it’s a hypothetical” | ||
Brooks now addresses the issue of ‘blagging’ or ‘pretexting’ | ||
Brooks says the Countess of Wessex Fake Sheikh operation, or cricket match fixing investigation is “a form of blagging or subterfuge” | ||
“It can be a simple as celebrity reporting ringing up a hotel and pretending to be an assistant,” says Brooks of blagging | ||
Rebekah Brooks question on the Hacking of Milly Dowlers Phone | ||
Shocked at the hacking of Milly Dowlers phone | ||
Brooks says she had nothing to do Glenn Mulcaire’s tasking by Neville Thurlbeck and hacking Milly’s phone. | ||
BREAKING: Brooks says she knew nothing of the NOTW hacking of Milly Dowler‘s phone until “4th July 2011 at 4 O’Clock” | ||
Brooks says she was “shocked” when she first heard in 2011. | ||
Brooks says she was told the voicemails were deleted and “gave her family a false hope she was alive…. it was abhorrent.” | ||
Brooks “Since that time… the voicemails weren’t deleted, and the police knew the voicemails were accessed… told the Dowlers at the time” | ||
“I had other things to contend with at the time,” Brooks says of July 2011 | ||
Brooks says a missing schoolgirl story would have been “very important” to her at the time. | ||
Brooks doesn’t agree that because of Sarah’s Law Campaign the Dowler story would have been especially significant. | ||
“When it first broke… the suggestion about Sarah’s Law may have been correct. It’s two years since Sarah had been murdered,” says Brooks | ||
“Sara Payne, and Mike, lived four or five streets away from Mr and Mrs Dowler, it may have been closer,” says Brooks. | ||
“The two missing Surrey schoolgirls,’ says Brooks explaining the connection: “could be… abduction by predatory paedophile” | ||
“You’re both doing fine,” says Justice Saunders in response to Brooks’ apology for not being clear. | ||
“I can’t remember day by day of the developments,” says Brooks “but I remember quick quickly being steered away from predatory paedophile” | ||
“I remember quite early on being told that the police didn’t think this was a case.. of a predatory paedophile abduction,” says Brooks | ||
Brooks says NSPCC and paedophile unit showed that child abuse by strangers is rare – their criticism of Sarah’s Campag | ||
Jury and Brooks is shown a “sensitive” document on the Dowler. | ||
Brooks agrees that the police attention was on Milly’s father at the time | ||
Brooks says this info at the time “had an impact” on her coverage of Milly Dowler: “we took the police’s line.” | ||
“There was a big pushback,” again Sara Payne writing something on Milly (though she lived near Dowlers) . | ||
Brooks in Dubai when the Milly Dowler story running | ||
Brooks says “Andy” was editing the paper on the week she was away in Dubai in early April 2002 | ||
Brooks reiterates the hacking of Milly’s phone was never brought to her attention at the time, or any time until July 2011 | ||
Laidlaw asks Brooks about her involvement in that edition of NOTW as the “absent editor” | ||
“The IT systems at NI were never the strongest point of the company,” says Brooks of difficulty accessing emails in 2002. | ||
“I remember using business centres, to dial into system, a key tag… it was laborious, quite slow,” says Brooks of accessing NI servers. | ||
“Email was not as easy as phone calls and texts,” says Brooks of 2002. | ||
“Whenever I went on holiday, my PA Cheryl would always know where I was…. I’d always have my mobile with me,” says Brooks #hackingtrial | ||
“It would be the latter half… around Thursday, Friday, Saturday,” Brooks says “that would be the kind of contact I’d expect” as NOTW ed | ||
“I can hazard a guess,” says Brooks of her calls at the time, depending on who the call was to and when back in 2002. | ||
Brooks “Looking at the newspaper itself, the edition of the 14th, I can put together… the kind of things I would have want to have known” | ||
“I would have been quite interested in the Michael Greco buy up, I was on holiday with Ross, And Michael a colleague of his,” says Brooks | ||
“I do remember it was a very expensive property,” says Brooks of Greco story. They’d been in a bidding war with other papers. | ||
“He and Ross shared a publicity agent… I’d secured the deal before I left,” says Brooks of Greco story. | ||
“I don’t remember a specific example,” Brooks says of Dowler story at the time: “There might have been an update… I don’t remember” | ||
Brooks explains the Michael Greco story was a joint deal with Sun: Les Hinton would get annoyed at bidding wars between NOTW and the Sun | ||
Brooks says she cannot remember the NOTW investigation in Telford: “I think I would remember if I got a call saying we found Milly Dolwer: | ||
Brooks says she remembers no discussion with police about voicemail left on Milly’s phone. | ||
“Ross and I were in a good place at the time,” says Brooks of 2002. “Andy and I were always close… we were good friends at the time.” | ||
Brooks says there was no physical intimacy with Andy Coulson at the time of the Dubai trip in April 2002 | ||
Run through of the Milly Dowler Timeline | ||
We move on to the NOTW Milly article on 24/04/02 – a week after the first. | ||
The NOTW from 23/04/02 edition covers Russell Crowe. Milly story on page 25. | ||
“It’s a very small story… way back in the paper,” says Brooks. “Because of distance of time I can’t remember when given steer by police.” | ||
“Presumably we have nothing on potential missing Surrey schoolgirl at this stage,” says Brooks of this edition of NOTW. | ||
Brooks has to move two bottles of water out the way to compare timelines with two other files. | ||
The jury have a note for the judge. | ||
The jury note is about a page inaccuracy. Edis explains it’s not an error. | ||
“Well spotted again,” says Justice Saunders of misattributed page noticed by the jury at the #hackingtrail | ||
“Please Come Home Darling” article from page 15 of NOTW shown to jury – this is the 2g – second edition 24/03/02 | ||
“Everyone is quite right about everything, and on that happy note we might break till 5 past two,” says Justice Saunders. | ||
Back at #hackingtrial in a chilly over air conditioned court room all say. Often too hot down here in the annex | ||
We’re now onto the 26/03/02 in Milly Dowler timeline. | ||
This is the Tuesday before 31/03/02 NOTW article – Milly comes up at Brooks’ conference with desk heads. | ||
Milly story is number 3: “At the top of the list are new things coming in,” says Brooks. “Where there was a development it went up the list” | ||
By the wednesday 28/03/03 “Milly Murder” at position no 2. “It changed to murder… I don’t know why,” says Brooks. | ||
Now to the Thursday 28/03/02 NOTW news list: “Milly’s Murder” still is 2nd place. | ||
29/03/02 Friday Afternoon list at NOTW: “Milly Murder” has fallen back on list. | ||
30/03/02 email from Kuttner to Fran Goodman, Clive’s sister, and was chief sub at the NOTW. “She’s brilliant,” says Brooks. | ||
Email from Kuttner is draft version of leaders about 2pm on 30/03/02: touches on Naomi Campbell’s case, and Dowler family “agony” | ||
Sara and Sarah Payne are mentioned in this draft NOTW leader about Dowler family anguish on 30/03/02 Jury shown newspaper file for 31/03/02 | ||
Front page of 31/03/02 NOTW is ‘Queen Mum is Dead’ – she died on the Saturday. “Massive impact on the paper,” says Brooks. | ||
Pages 1-7 of that NOTW edition dominated by Queen Mother’s death, with additional pull out section. Milly story on pp’s 21-23 | ||
Brooks thinks there’s “nothing obvious” at this point she had a ‘steer’ from the police away from Sarah Payne style stranger abduction | ||
“Presumably we were given it by police,” says Brooks of letter that steered her away from stranger abduction of Milly Dowler in 2002 | ||
The following week 03/04/02 ‘Missing Milly’ is top of the Thursday NOTW news schedule. “Dando Killer” at number two – it makes NOTW splash | ||
At the end of this third quarter into 2002, Miskiw, Judy McGuire and Gary Thompson are both given bonuses for keeping under weekly limits | ||
Dando Killer, Queen Mother and Milly story lead the NOTW news schedule on the Friday in April 2002 | ||
07/04/02 edition of NOTW – Brooks says she edited it. Jill Dando and Barry George story is on the front page. | ||
On pages 10 and 11 of NOTW that Sunday is the Milly Dowler story. | ||
07/04/02 the police have released CCTV images: “the ‘steer’ wouldn’t have been released to the press for obvious reasons” | ||
Brooks talks about Rachel MacClean story and boyfriend making a public appeal: “reporters knew already he was their number one suspect” | ||
“I wouldn’t have gone on holiday if I thought it was a Sarah’s Law situation,” says Brooks of Dowler that weekend. | ||
“We’d be helping the police as much as we could,” says Brooks. “It could be the beginnings of their provisional belief it was closer to home | ||
Jury are shown Brooks’ desk diary for 07/04/02 showing ‘Holiday’ entered by Cheryl Carter. | ||
Brooks says she travelled on the Sunday to Dubai, but can’t remember the time. | ||
“By this point in 2002 we had quite a lot of the legislation for Sarah’s Law,” says Brooks, but there was still a long way to go. | ||
Brooks said she would have cancelled holiday if the story was moving in Sarah Payne direction: she regularly cancelled holidays. | ||
“I flew back from a holiday during Soham,” says Brooks of breaking stories interrupted her holidays. | ||
“Ross liked Dubai,” says Brooks: “That would be a reason to go there. We were going to get married… we may have been looking for…” | ||
Brooks says she and Ross Kemp went to Dubai several times. This definitely wasn’t the first. | ||
Brooks remembers William Hennessy and Dean Keyworth having to change hotels in Dubai. “I think I had met Dean before,” she says. | ||
“I think he was an old school friend of Andy’s,” says Brooks of Keyworth. But had “definitely not” met William Hennessy. | ||
Brooks says “I do remember meeting Dean” in Dubai that week in April 2002 | ||
“It seems quite a lot of time,” says Brooks of 5-6 hour meeting with Keyworth and Hennessy, but says it could have happened. | ||
Of being on the phone 50% of that time, Brooks says “when I see the phone records it does look like I was on the phone a lot” | ||
As to Hennessy’s evidence that Brooks had to talk to someone “about the missing Surrey girl” Brooks says “I can’t remember but it’s possible | ||
“It would be more normal for me to say their name…. ‘I have to go and talk about Milly Dowler… (not) ‘Missing Surrey schoolgirl’ Brooks | ||
“Because Sarah’s Law was quite controversial, people would often bring it up with me. I got into pattern of…. defending it quite strongly” | ||
Laidlaw adduces an email message from Emma Hardy, Coulson’s PA, “effectively the editor’s PA when you’re away” | ||
Brooks says “pretty much every department and deputies” addressed in internal NOTW “think tank” email about “4 core readers” on 16/04/02 | ||
“At the Sun there was a promotion for… a caravan park holiday for £9.50. Incredibly popular promotion the Sun” cross promoted at NOTW | ||
“I thought it would be a good if…. me and my executives went on a £9.50 holiday… 2 million readers, incredibly popular” says Brooks. | ||
“I did it every year at the Sun” says Brooks of this think tank at £9.50 holiday. | ||
Brooks says she would have had “very little knowledge” of these Tuesday 09/04/02 NOTW editorial discussions when she was in Dubai. | ||
Call billings show Brooks making lots of calls to her voicemail from Dubai that Tuesday. | ||
Jury shown 09/04/02 Brooks billing details – 5 voicemail checks. | ||
Wednesday 10/04/02 ‘Missing Milly’ now half way down the NOTW news story list. Thurlbeck tasks Mulcaire with Dowler number. | ||
Thursday 11/04/02 Missing Milly still on the NOTW news list. On voicemail access by Brooks on 10th, on 11th several calls and texts | ||
There are three incoming texts to Brooks’ phone on the 11th. Call to Kemp’s agents at the Artist Rights Group | ||
There’s a call at 12.44 to the editor’s desk in London: “Andy would move into editor’s office when I’m away. His PA would move with him” | ||
Brooks calls Dave Reid the publicity agent soon after that day: “Putting 2 and 2 together… that weekend we had the Michael Greco,” | ||
Brooks on call to McGuire: “Judy is the editor of the Sunday magazine and very good friend of mine… more likely to be personal” | ||
Brooks calls the editor’s office and the Artist Rights Group on that Thursday: “Not at all unusual,” she says of number of calls | ||
Friday 12/04/02 Milly still on NOTW schedule: 12 calls that day by Brooks from Dubai. 3 to editors desk. One for 30 mins. | ||
There are also four texts to Andy Coulson on 12/04/03 | ||
“It’s Friday evening,” says Brooks of 40 min call to editor’s desk: “Usually the time to check in” | ||
“You can talk through any issues that have come up… the main stories, promotions and marketing. Arguments with management.” Brooks says | ||
“Rather than talk through every story blow by blow,” Brooks says the call could be about “balance” in the NOTW. | ||
“By the time I left NI we had a system call Karma, and we could see the newspapers as they were being built,” says Brooks. | ||
“It was much easier to keep in touch with visual look of paper… back then it wouldn’t have been easy or possible,” says Brooks | ||
On 12/04/02 Thurlbeck contacted the recruitment agency in Telford. Hacking of Milly’s phone must have happened by now. | ||
Brooks says she would have told any journalist who had a lead about Milly Dowler at that point: “Tell the police” | ||
“The parents… you’d want to tell them immediately,” says Brooks of any info on Milly Dowler. She says she wouldn’t hold onto for a story | ||
That Friday afternoon UK time there are four texts from/to Andy Coulson 12/04/03 – not clear yet which | ||
3 calls to the editorial desk that Friday evening 12/04/02 “I’m ringing the front bench… for a run through of.. what they were running” | ||
10 minute break | ||
Saturday 13/04/02 moving between calls and timeline: two morning calls to editor’s desk. | ||
These are both calls to the back bench – Harry Scott’s desk at NOTW. | ||
A 20 minute call to the editor’s desk around noon. Brooks says there were conferences around 11 am. | ||
Brooks says she’s “assuming… I’m ringing in to get an update from my deputy… it would have been a good time. “ | ||
At this point on Sat 13/04/02 there’s an email from Ian Kirby about KRM: “Keith is the late man this evening” – was Kirby’s deputy. | ||
Main stories of the day on the Saturday 13/04/02 are listed on this email. Brooks says she could get emails through laptop. | ||
“Rupert Murdoch would always ring his Sunday editors on a Saturday evening… what would be in the paper tomorrow,” Brooks says. | ||
“It could be any time around the first edition,” Brooks says of the Murdoch’s call. “Particularly the budget coming up following week” | ||
Brooks calls her mum, and Daresbury properties that afternoon. | ||
A text from Brooks at 21.04 (UK time) to Armstrong and Keyworth, then to Coulson 4 mins later, a text back from Coulson. | ||
“Not particularly” says Brooks to a question about what she remembers. But it may be about the meeting with Coulson’s friend Keyworth. | ||
“Somehow we managed to meet up for a drink,” says Brooks of Keyworth text. Justice Saunders suggests jury add this to the timeline. | ||
That Saturday evening there’s a short call of 15 seconds to the Editor’s desk around 9.15 pm. Rival papers come in. Murdoch might call | ||
Laidlaw goes through the three editions of the Dowler story: 1st around 7pm “Milly Hoax Riddle: Message on Mobile Probed” by Rob Kellaway | ||
Article sets out the voice mail messages “Hello Mandy” and tone of voice on Milly’s voicemail | ||
On page 9 of 2G – second edition of NOTW – the byline has changed but the article is the same. This is main selling edition. | ||
2nd Edition around 9pm. 3rd edition around 11 pm on 13/04/02 the message on Milly Dowler‘s phone is omitted from NOTW article. | ||
By the time of third edition, a SBS story has bumped the Dowler story back. | ||
Mention of Voicemails removed from Milly Dowler article | ||
BREAKING: Brooks says she had no part to play in any of the changes to the Dowler story which omitted references to voicemails | ||
Brooks returned on the Sunday 14th from Dubai but “there’s no record” of what time that day. | ||
Laidlaw cites a £1000 plus list of costs “Missing Milly” is billed for £2k under editorial budget: a contingency fund. Brooks never seen doc | ||
Brooks explains a Circulation, losses and lateness report which shows where NOTW missed sales because of late delivery | ||
Brooks cannot recall what she on that Monday she returned from Dubai, except a Monday think tank at £9.50 Caravan Park holiday with readers | ||
“The diary says Think Tanks so I assume that’s what I was doing… the majority were away from the office,” says Brooks. | ||
Brooks says she would read a paper published in her absence. | ||
“We lived in Battersea, so we got the late editions delivered to the house,” says Brooks of the Dowler story. | ||
Brooks says she would have only read the third edition of NOTW when she was away. | ||
Brooks explains the “streets” edition which would spoof the front page to stop MoS “matching” the story. | ||
The third edition of NOTW was the big seller says Brooks, because it has final football match analysis | ||
“I would have scanned through… rather than read every single line…” says Brooks of NOTW paper. “I may have noticed it was a new picture” | ||
“I’m on page 30, I’m scanning through the book. I’ve got all the other papers to read. Quite a big job to read them all,” says Brooks | ||
Brooks says she wasn’t back at the Wapping Office till the Wednesday 17/04/02 because of think tank at Caravan Park. | ||
Missing Milly is at 5th position now in NOTW news schedule. Another email from Ian Kirby, political ed with Chancellor “budget information” | ||
“I probably watch it in my office,” says Brooks of budget. “I do remember this increase in national insurance.” | ||
This is a document the defence has introduced from prosecution disclosure. | ||
“I remember quite a few meetings with Gordon Brown about this rise,” says Brooks of 1% NI rise hypothecated to NHS | ||
By the thursday 18/04/02 Missing Milly story is half way down the news schedule of NOTW. Moves up and down on the Friday 19/04/02 | ||
Kuttner email to Surrey Police | ||
On Friday 19/04/02 16.04 Kuttner emails Sarah McGregor at Surrey Police about Milly story – not copied to anyone else. | ||
Brooks says Kuttner email was never drawn to her attention, nor it’s content “No, I don’t think so.” | ||
Brooks says she was at a friend’s hen weekend, she says on the 20/04/02 but worked most of Saturday until first edition. | ||
Jane Moore was the ‘hen’ at that hen weekend abroad. “From memory hen weekend started on Saturday and ended on a Monday… afternoon” | ||
Brooks does not recall seeing a second email from Kuttner: she doesn’t remember the contents “not at the time, no” | ||
21/04/02 edition of NOTW has another Milly story marked ‘Exclusive’ “though sometimes exclusive is overused,” says Brooks. | ||
“It stands to reason this was the story on the newslist for the preceding few days,” Brooks says of Dowler story on 21/04/02 | ||
Rebekah Brooks replies to Bob Bird email on that Saturday: “Sven is good” talks about top line for Scottish edition. | ||
‘Missing Milly” still on NOTW news list following Wednesday, Thursday and Friday: falls down and then promoted on 26/04/02. | ||
NOTW Milly article on 28/04/02 talks about ‘testing’. A some point before this story “the steer came through it was closer to home” | ||
“At some point the police interviewed… Mr Dowler…. There was a moment the police put the white tents over the house,” says Brooks. | ||
“We were being briefed about the backstory on this,” says Brooks about the NOTW story on the 28/04/02. | ||
Dowler story on news list on 01/05/02: email discusses the reward. “Stuart Kuttner would often deal with the police on this kind of thing” | ||
“If they knew what really happened, the reward would cause confusion….. the police would receive too many crank calls…” says Brooks | ||
Sorry – Laidlaw got it wrong – this is 1st of May not June. 01/05/02 | ||
The Dowler reward turned into a shared reward with the Sun. 05/04/02 there’s a two page colour spread on the NOTW reward. | ||
NOTW article 12/05/02 Retracing Milly’s last steps 23/06/02 Milly still missing, appeal for information: September Milly’s body recovered. | ||
Saunders explains he cannot sit on Friday March 7th. (He says May by mistake and is corrected). Back tomorrow at 10 am |
Note: All the defendants deny all the charges. The trial continues.
Related Articles
Peter Jukes on ABC Radio
Rebekah Brooks Takes The Stand At Phone Hacking Trial – The Daily Beast
The Brooks Plan B and Blair Unofficial Advisor emails
Half Time at the Phone Hacking Trial
How the Kindness of Strangers crowd funded my Hacking Trial coverage
Previous Posts
Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 19 Feb
Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 20 Feb
Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 21 Feb
Links: The Trial So Far | Full Trial Summary | Indexed Evidence | Breaking News
It was interesting how the Sarah Payne law and Milly Dowler were connected in Brooks’ mind and journalistic practice.
When and where were there times when Brooks called a piece exclusive that should not have been called exclusive?
Pingback: Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 26 Feb | Live Tweeting the hacking trial
Pingback: Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 27 Feb | Live Tweeting the hacking trial
Pingback: Hacking Trial Live Tweets – 28 Feb | Live Tweeting the hacking trial